If your phone goes unanswered while you are on a job, you have three ways to fix it: hire someone, pay a telephone answering service, or use an AI receptionist. This guide compares the last two.
A note before we start. We build AI receptionists, so weigh what follows accordingly. Our phone version is built to order and has not yet gone live for a client, so nothing here is a claim about results. It is a description of how the two differ.
How each one works
A telephone answering service diverts your calls to a call centre. A person answers in your company's name, usually from a script you have agreed, takes the caller's details and sends you a message. Some services will also book appointments into a diary you share with them.
An AI receptionist diverts your calls to software. It answers at once, says it is an AI assistant, asks the questions you have set, and either books the caller in or passes them to a person with a record of the conversation. The same assistant can usually handle web chat and email, so an enquiry is dealt with the same way however it arrives.
Where each is better
| AI receptionist | Telephone answering service | |
|---|---|---|
| Speed of answer | Immediate, at any hour | Depends on the service and how busy it is |
| Several callers at once | Yes | Depends on staffing |
| Asking detailed, job-specific questions | Good: the same questions, asked the same way, every time | Varies with the script and the person |
| Booking into your diary | Yes, where your diary allows it | Some services do |
| Upset, confused or vulnerable callers | Weaker. These should be handed to a person | Better |
| Unusual requests | Weaker. It should say so and take a message | Better |
| A record of every call | Yes, written up automatically | Usually a message summary |
Neither column wins outright. A person is better at the calls that need judgement and warmth. Software is better at being there at once, every time, with the right questions.
How each is charged
Answering services usually charge a monthly fee, with calls or minutes on top or included up to a limit. The cost therefore rises with how busy you are, which is also when you most need the cover. Compare providers on the total for your real call volume, not the headline price.
An AI receptionist is usually a fixed price. Ours is 10% of the yearly salary of the person who handles your enquiries, or would, per year, with a minimum of £2,400 a year. Phone calls cost money per minute to run, so a monthly allowance is agreed up front and included.
Whichever you look at, ask what happens to the bill in your busiest month.
Which suits you
An AI receptionist tends to suit you if:
- most of your calls are enquiries that follow a pattern, such as quotes, bookings and "do you cover my area?"
- you miss calls because you are working, not because you are closed
- calls arrive in bursts, or in the evening and at weekends
- you want the enquiry in your diary or job system, not in a message to read later
An answering service tends to suit you if:
- your callers are often distressed or need careful handling
- calls are varied and hard to script
- your customers expect to speak to a person and would take their business elsewhere if they could not
Both together is common sense for many firms: the assistant answers first, deals with the routine, and passes anything else to a person, whether that is you or a service.
Before you sign up to either
Ask each supplier the same five questions.
- What exactly does the caller hear, and can I listen to an example?
- What happens to calls it cannot deal with?
- How does the enquiry reach me, and how fast?
- What is recorded or kept, for how long, and who can see it?
- What does it cost in a month with twice my usual calls?
Then check the answer against your own numbers. Our missed enquiry calculator works out what unanswered enquiries are costing you a year, from figures you enter. If the answer is "not much", you may not need either.