Skip to content

← All insights

Lead sites · Guides

Is Checkatrade worth it? How to work it out from your own numbers

By Rob Dale ·

In short

  • Whether a lead site is worth it depends on one number: what you pay for each job you win, set against what a job earns you.
  • You need four figures for the last three months: what you paid, how many enquiries came from the site, how many you won, and what those jobs left you after costs.
  • Two firms on the same site get different results because of what happens after the enquiry arrives: how fast they reply, and whether they chase the quote.
  • Before you leave a site that is not paying, check how many of its enquiries you actually answered.

Ask ten tradespeople whether Checkatrade is worth it and you will get ten answers, most of them strongly held. That is because the honest answer is "it depends on your numbers", and almost nobody has worked theirs out.

This guide does not tell you whether to join or leave. We have no connection with Checkatrade or any other lead site, we do not know what you pay, and we are not going to quote their prices, which vary by trade and area and change over time. What it gives you is a way to answer the question for your own firm in about an hour, with a pen.

The same method works for MyBuilder, Rated People, Bark or any directory that charges you to be found.

What you are actually buying

A lead site sells you one of three things, and it helps to know which.

  • A listing. You pay to appear, with your reviews and a badge, and customers contact you. The cost is fixed whether the phone rings or not.
  • Leads. You pay for each enquiry sent to you, or each one you choose to respond to. The cost rises with volume, and you pay for the ones you lose as well as the ones you win.
  • A mix. A membership fee plus a charge per lead or per job.

Check which you are on now. People are often paying for a package they chose years ago.

The only number that matters

It is not the monthly fee, and it is not the number of leads. It is what you pay for each job you win, set against what a job earns you.

To get it you need four figures for the last three months.

  1. What you paid. Every charge from the site: membership, leads, extras. Take it from your bank statement, not from memory.
  2. How many enquiries came from it. Calls, messages and quote requests that you can trace to the site.
  3. How many of those you won.
  4. What those jobs were worth to you. Not the invoice total. What was left after materials and anyone you paid.

If you cannot produce the second and third, that is your first finding. Most firms cannot, because nobody asks "where did you find us?" and writes down the answer. Start doing that today, for every enquiry, in a notebook or a spreadsheet. A month from now you will have real figures.

The sum

The numbers below are made up to show the working. Put your own in.

Say that over three months you paid £600 in total. You had 30 enquiries from the site and won 6 jobs. Those 6 jobs left you £2,400 after costs.

  • Cost per enquiry: £600 divided by 30 is £20.
  • Cost per job won: £600 divided by 6 is £100.
  • What a job earned: £2,400 divided by 6 is £400.
  • What came back: £2,400 from £600 spent. Four pounds for every pound.

On those figures it is clearly paying. Now change one number. Say you won 2 jobs, not 6, and they left you £800.

  • Cost per job won: £600 divided by 2 is £300.
  • What came back: £800 from £600 spent.

That is barely worth the phone calls. Nothing about the site changed. The difference is how many enquiries turned into work.

Why two firms get different answers

The enquiries a site sends are much the same for every firm in your trade and area. What happens next is down to you, and it is where the money is won or lost.

  • How fast you reply. On a lead site the customer has often contacted several firms at once. The first to come back with a sensible answer is in front. If you reply that evening, you are often replying to someone who has already booked.
  • Whether you reply at all. Enquiries that arrive while you are on a job and are never returned still cost you money.
  • Whether you chase the quote. Plenty of work goes to whoever followed up, not whoever was cheapest.
  • Your reviews. On a listing, they are most of what the customer has to go on.
  • Which jobs you take. Small jobs a long drive away can make a busy month an unprofitable one.

So before you decide the site is not worth it, check whether it is the leads or the handling. If you paid for 30 enquiries and only spoke to 18 of them, the first fix is free: answer the other 12.

Deciding

Once you have three months of honest figures, the choice is usually plain.

  • It pays, and you have capacity. Keep it. Consider whether faster replies would win you more from the same spend.
  • It pays, but you are turning work away. You may be paying for enquiries you cannot use. Ask whether a smaller package exists.
  • It does not pay, and you are slow to reply. Fix the replies first and measure again for a month before you leave.
  • It does not pay, and you are quick, and you chase. It is not working for your trade and area. Check the notice period and go.

Compare it with your other sources in the same way: what you spend on your website, your van, your Google listing, and what each brings in. In many small firms the best source is recommendation, which costs nothing. Your figures will show whether that is true for you.

Where we come in, and where we do not

We do not sell leads. We build systems that deal with the enquiries you already get, such as an assistant that replies within minutes at any hour and asks the questions your office would ask. You can try a working example.

That only helps if slow or missed replies are your problem. To find out what unanswered enquiries cost you in a year, from your own figures, use the missed enquiry calculator. If the answer is small, your money is better spent elsewhere, and the calculator will tell you so.

Questions

How much does Checkatrade cost?

We do not quote other companies' prices. What you pay depends on your trade, your area and the package, and it changes. Ask for the current figure in writing, then put it through the sum in this guide.

Does the same method work for MyBuilder, Rated People and Bark?

Yes. They charge in different ways, some per lead and some by membership, but the question is the same: what did you pay in total, and what did the jobs you won leave you after costs?

How do I know which enquiries came from the site?

Ask every caller where they found you and write it down, in a notebook or a spreadsheet. Some sites also give you a tracking phone number or a list of leads sent. After a month you will have figures you can trust.

What if I win the jobs but they are not profitable?

Then the site is sending the wrong work, or you are pricing it too low. Use what a job leaves you after materials and labour in the sum, not the invoice total. A site can look busy and still lose you money.

Next step

Find out what's worth automating first.

A 30-minute call. We look at where your team’s hours go and what your marketing returns, then tell you honestly whether an AI system would pay back. No deck, no pressure.